Not sure how often this area is even viewed any more but figured it was worth a shot.

I'm in a $200/team, 12 man keeper league - which I won last year! In this league, we're able to keep up to 2 players. If you keep the player, you forfeit the draft pick in which you selected the player last year. I'll be drafting 12th. It's a PPR league for what that's worth as well. Starts 2 RB, 2 WR and a flex spot.

Here are my keeper options:

Jamaal Charles - 1st round
Calvin Johnson - 1st round
DeMarco Murray - 3rd round
Eric Decker - 6th round
Seattle D/ST - 9th round
Knowshown Moreno - 10th round
Cordarelle Patterson - 10th round

I can only keep Charles OR Johnson, not both. I traded for Johnson during the year but league rules state that you can't keep more than 1 first round pick.

I've more or less decided on keeping Charles and sacrificing pick #12 (I'll still have pick #13). I briefly considered Johnson, but that doesn't seem like the right move. Thoughts on that?

My bigger concern is my second keeper. I've narrowed it down to Murray or Patterson. Patterson would have better value as a 10th round keeper, but at the same time, with RB so, so thin this year that keeping Murray gives me 2 of the few bell cow RB's - and gives me 2 players in the top 20 going into the draft, though giving up two early picks is a bit scary. My thought being I could keep Charles and Murray and then be free to take whatever I want with my first pick - a third RB if one happens to fall, or a WR or whatever. Where if I keep Patterson and no RB falls, I could be stuck with a rather undesirable RB situation. I've tried to guess what others would keep and if my guesses are close, Murray would be the 5th best player back in the draft.

Thoughts? What would everyone do?